Skip to content

Gallstones Vs Kidney Stone Pain: 8 Differences

Dr QM Leong
Dr QM Leong

Misconceptions frequently abound when it comes to the comparison of gallstones and kidney stones. Both are “hard lumps” or rocks that form in the body, resulting in significant discomfort, but crucial differences exist.

This article seeks to dispel such confusion by detailing these differences and providing valuable insights into these two conditions.


Understanding Gallstones

Gallstone Vs Kidney Stone Pain

Gallstones or gallbladder stones are hard particles that develop in the bile duct or gallbladder, a small organ under the liver. The gallbladder’s primary role is to store bile, a fluid the liver produces to digest fat. Gallstones can form when there’s too much cholesterol or bilirubin in your bile.

Symptoms of gallstones may include:

  • Intense pain in the upper-right section of your abdomen.
  • Back pain between your shoulder blades.
  • Pain in your right shoulder.

Treatment often involves medication to dissolve the gallstones or, in severe cases, gallbladder removal through surgery.


Understanding Kidney Stones

On the other hand, kidney stones are solid masses made of crystals that originate in your kidneys. These stones can consist of calcium, struvite, uric acid, or cystine stones. Smaller kidney stones might pass on their own, causing little or no pain.

However, larger kidney stones can be quite painful, with the discomfort typically felt in the back or side below the ribs, travelling to the lower abdomen and groyne. Drinking ample water, pain medication, and medical procedures are common ways to find relief or remove these stones.


Differences Between Gallstones And Kidney Stones

The distinctions between kidney stones and gallstones are noteworthy. Let’s delve into these differences:


1. Stone Composition

Kidney stones comprise calcium, though uric acid stones and struvite stones can also occur. Conversely, gallstones mostly contain cholesterol or bilirubin.


2. Medical Terminology

The term for kidney stones is nephrolithiasis, while cholelithiasis refers to gallstones.


3. Causes

Various factors can cause kidney stones, including dehydration, protein-rich diets, sodium and sugar, obesity, and certain medical conditions. In contrast, gallstones form due to too much cholesterol or bilirubin in the bile, rapid weight loss, or blood disorders.


4. Common Symptoms

Both can cause severe pain, but the location of the pain is typically different. Kidney stones cause pain in the back or side below the ribs, while gallstones cause pain in the upper right of your abdomen.


5. Prevention

Drinking enough water helps prevent kidney stones, while a low-fat and low-cholesterol diet can prevent gallstones.


6. Treatment

For kidney stones, treatment could range from hydration and pain management to surgery, depending on the stone size. For gallstones, doctors may recommend gallbladder removal.


7. Risk Groups

Specific demographics are at a higher risk of developing these stones. For kidney stones, men are more commonly affected. For gallstones, women, people over 40, and individuals whose family members have a history of gallstones may have a higher risk.


8. Location Of Pain

Pain from gallstones is typically felt in the upper-right section of your abdomen, while kidney stones can lead to lower abdomen and back pain.


Similarities Between Gallstones And Kidney Stones

Despite their differences, gallstones and kidney stones share some commonalities. Both cause significant pain and discomfort and can lead to severe complications if left untreated. Some dietary habits, like eating a high-fat, sodium, and sugar diet, can contribute to developing both gallstones and kidney stones.


How To Prevent Gallstones And Kidney Stones

Here are steps to reduce your risk of developing either kidney or gallstones:

  • Hydration: Adequate fluid intake is paramount, particularly water. Hydration helps dilute the substances in urine that lead to stones. Practise proper hydration by drinking at least eight glasses of water daily.
  • Balanced Diet: Nutrient-dense foods are critical for overall health and to ward off these conditions. Incorporate fruits, leafy greens, lean meat, and whole grains into your diet.
  • Limit Sodium Intake: A diet high in sodium may increase the likelihood of kidney stones in your body. This is because it causes higher levels of calcium in your urine. For gallstones, it leads to increased cholesterol in bile. Reduce your consumption of processed foods, fast food, and table salt, typically high in sodium.
  • Increase Dietary Fibre: A fibre-rich diet can help your body remove excess cholesterol, reducing the risk of gallstones. Foods like legumes, fruits, vegetables, and are excellent sources of fibre.
  • Healthy Weight Maintenance: Strive for a balanced weight. Rapid weight loss can lead to an increased risk of gallstones. Regular exercise and healthy weight maintenance can also decrease your risk of kidney stones.
  • Regular Exercise: Physical activity can help manage body weight and prevent gallstones. For kidney stones, exercise helps to reduce blood pressure and decreases the amount of calcium the kidneys need to filter, thereby reducing the risk of stone formation.
  • Limit Intake of Oxalate-rich Foods: For those prone to calcium oxalate kidney stones, reduce the consumption of oxalate-rich foods like spinach, rhubarb, and certain nuts and teas.
  • Control Protein Intake: Consuming a lot of animal-based proteins can increase uric acid levels, leading to both uric acid stones and calcium stones. Opt for plant-based proteins or lean meats in moderation.
  • Cautious Use of Supplements: Excessive consumption of vitamin C and calcium supplements can contribute to stone formation. Consume these supplements judiciously and under medical supervision.


Conclusion On Gallstones Vs Kidney Stones

Understanding the differences between gallstones and kidney stones is paramount to early detection and proper treatment. Despite the discomfort they cause, lifestyle modifications and medical interventions can help manage and prevent these conditions. Always consult a healthcare provider when experiencing symptoms for proper diagnosis and treatment.

Need treatment for your gallstones? Gallstone removal is one of Dr Leong’s fields of expertise. He can perform professional gallbladder surgery in Singapore for those in need using the latest medical equipment and techniques.

Schedule a consultation now or visit his clinic at Mount Alvernia Hospital, Medical Centre A.


Frequently Asked Questions On Gallstones Vs Kidney Stones

What Does Kidney Stone Pain Feel Like?

The pain of kidney stones is often described as excruciating pain starting in the lower back or flank, often spreading to the groin. The pain comes in waves and fluctuates in intensity.

Can Gallstones Turn Into Kidney Stones?

No, gallstones and kidney stones are different conditions. They develop in separate body parts and cannot transform into one another.

How Do I Check Myself For Kidney Stones?

You cannot reliably check yourself for kidney stones. If you suspect the presence of kidney stones in your body due to persistent pain or urinary changes, seek medical attention immediately.

What Foods Can Cause Kidney Stones?

High-oxalate foods, such as spinach, rhubarb, and nuts, can result in the formation of calcium oxalate kidney stones. Additionally, a diet high in sodium and animal proteins might increase the risk.

Do Gallstones Form In The Urinary Tract?

No, gallstones form in the gallbladder, not the urinary tract. They can, however, block the bile ducts, causing symptoms of pain and changes in digestion.

Can Gallstones And Kidney Stones Lead To Liver Disease?

While gallstones and kidney stones do not lead to liver disease, they can cause complications if they block the bile ducts, potentially leading to liver issues.

What Are Other Symptoms Of Kidney Stones Or Gallstones?

Besides causing symptoms of severe pain, kidney stones may cause cloudy or foul-smelling urine, frequent urination, and nausea. Conversely, gallstones may cause jaundice (yellowing of the skin and eyes), high temperature, and chills.

What Colour Is Your Urine When You Have Gallstones?

Gallstones themselves do not change the colour of urine. However, if a gallstone blocks the bile duct, it can lead to darker urine due to increased bilirubin levels.

Related Articles